If you have a dual groove pulley on the air conditioning, I'm sure you need two belts across it. I would expect one belt to be tightened by the alternator and the other to be tightened by the idler pulley. I vaguely recall if the idler pulley is at the top, you need a long belt that goes around the alternator, air conditioning, water pump, and crank pulley. The second belt goes AC, idler pulley, water pump, crank. The third belt goes crank, water pump, power steering.
If this does not line up, I'd guess you have the wrong water pump. The water pump thing is really common on these cars - quality makers like GMB sell the
wrong pump for these Jeeps. You can remove the fan and water pump pulley and see the front of the water pump. Then you can recognize the type of pump you have.
This is the right pump:
This is the wrong pump that GMB lists for this application:
GMBpump (565 x 352).jpg
You don't need to measure - the front bearing on the wrong pump is larger than on the right pump. The housing also has ribs to support the front bearing that are missing on the right pump.
Look at the '72 RockAuto listing; it's wrong. At least they give the hub height - likely a CYA for selling the wrong pump. With slightly more honesty, the listings for '71 show no pump available.
https://www.rockauto.com/en/catalog/jee ... +pump,2208
(Not the fault of RockAuto - I'm sure they simply copy the listings that the parts makers give them).
I looked at the '72 TSM, but the belt diagram is different from what you have - no idler pulley on top. Possible the Jeep TSM supplement for 1971 shows the correct belt diagram. If you are still struggling with this, I'd suggest you find the Jeep part numbers for the 1971 belts and see if the online listings will provide a length. The lengths may be in the parts book. This will give some additional indication of whether you've got it right.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.