Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Modified FSJ Tech Area
Post Reply
User avatar

Topic author
bigwalton
Posts: 161
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2012 10:33 am
Location: MI

Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by bigwalton »

Only putting this here because I have an Edelbrock 1406 and Mallory Hei on a 360 with an RV cam and fresh rebuild. Swapped in an eBay electric fuel pump on the frame rail that sends fuel to engine through the stock hard line and then new rubber line to carb.

Engine idles all day long great and revs in the garage fine, never an issue.

While driving, I've had two different things happen very intermittently and I can't reproduce/predict the situation.

1. Engine drops out for just a quick second and then is fine. Not like its ladling/coasting, like it engine brakes for a quick blip and then has no problem. Happened during hard accel and cruising, never at idle yet.

Ran a new hot on run power feed to HEI/choke. Choke opening fine.

2. Prolonged stumbling like its out of gas while cruising/accelerating for up to a few seconds. Varies as to how long it lasts and whether it turns the engine off or not, usually not. Thought this was only with low fuel, but today I put in $20 and it happened soon after, but it passed pretty quick. When I got home, let it idle in N on the garage with no issues and revved fine.

No fuel leaks anywhere that I see/smell, fuel cap drilled to vent. Fuel filter outlet properly oriented with return at 12 o'clock. No emissions. New fuel filter at engine, clear prefilter from tank before pump is clean. Newer/good condition rubber EFI line from tank to pump. New lines in engine bay. Steel lines on rail look good.

Jeep did sit for years before I replaced engine and resurrected it, but it runs/idles so well in the garage that I just ran with it without rebuilding carb (Edelbrock was new and only ran a hundred miles or so before head gasket made PO park the Jeep). Mallory is a few year old unit, but new, was never installed on old engine.

Any thoughts on things to check that I might have missed?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
'77 Cherokee S - EFI 401
'84 Alaskan Postal Scrambler
'18 JKU Rubi Recon
'01 XJ - kid's DD
'01 XJ - winter beater
'18 Renegade
User avatar

[ O o \\|// o O ]
Posts: 226
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 3:15 pm

Re: Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by [ O o \\|// o O ] »

I had a strange runability issue that was very intermittent and seemed completely unrelated to anything.
Some times it stuttered, some times it died, it was never consistent but it always started fine.
Digging around under the dash I noticed the plug on the on the ignition switch was a little loose. Pushed it on tight and everything was good again.
User avatar

Topic author
bigwalton
Posts: 161
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2012 10:33 am
Location: MI

Re: Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by bigwalton »

Interesting, I have been under there messing around with a number of things, I'll definitely check.
'77 Cherokee S - EFI 401
'84 Alaskan Postal Scrambler
'18 JKU Rubi Recon
'01 XJ - kid's DD
'01 XJ - winter beater
'18 Renegade
User avatar

jaber
Vendor
Posts: 3067
Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2011 5:24 pm
Location: Chino Valley, Az.

Re: Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by jaber »

I have also had the ignition switch (electric switch under dash) start to come apart. The metal tabs that hold the plastic in had relaxed and it made for some weird ghosts...
Jeff

'46 cj3a
'51 Willys p/u
'51 Willys Parkway Conversion
'74 CJ5
'75 J-20 Wrecker
'75 J-20 Cummins service truck
'77 J-10 p/u
'79 Cherokee
'88 Grand Wagoneer
http://s252.photobucket.com/albums/hh14/jeffaber/
User avatar

Topic author
bigwalton
Posts: 161
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2012 10:33 am
Location: MI

Re: Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by bigwalton »

Well, I appreciate the input. I did check the switch and one plug did push on somewhat when I checked that it was tight.

However, I was going to be thorough and also checked a number of other things as well. Of course I did all of them last night without driving it between them, so if it's fixed I won't know which one it was.

I pulled the carb cover off and found that there was some varnish-y looking crud on the bottom of the passenger side bowl. Cleaned it out well.

While I was at that, I checked the springs in the carb and saw that they were the heavy silver springs (8mmHg) where the carb instructions say that stock should be the orange 5mmHg, so I swapped those in. Rods/jets were stock. Figured that I'd get back to the initial settings and go from there.

On the Mallory, I pulled the top off and saw that the power wire to the coil had been somewhat crushed when I put the cap on last. It's just a solid wire, not stranded, and it was still very sturdy, but the insulation was pretty mashed. I straightened it out and put some liquid electrical tape over the mashed bit to prevent any possible arcing.

I also noticed that the screw for the cover in the corner that has the grounding tab for the coil had stripped out the screw hole, guess I overtightened it the last time I reassembled it. I was worried that this might affect the grounding of the coil, so I soldered a wire with an eye on it to the grounding tab and ran it back to the next cover hole to double up on the ground to the coil. I made sure not to overtighten it this time. I'll try to find a longer long screw for the one corner.

While I was in there, I pulled the cap and the Mallory ignition module to inspect them. Both looked fine, but the red power wire to the module was positioned where the module squeezed it against the vacuum advance rod quite hard. The insulation on the wire was dented in (not cut or broken though) quite well where the rod had worked back and forth across it. Seems like a design flaw to me on the module because there's no really clear/good way to route that wire. I tried to gently reorganize the red and brown wires that were working together to cause the problem and while the red is still touching the rod, it's definitely not stuck between the module and rod as badly.

Lastly, while inside the HEI, I noticed that the round rubber isolator/cushion in the cap under the coil was off center. It looked like it might have artificially compressed and pushed off-center the spring that goes from the rotor button to the bottom of the coil, so I straightened those. I also noticed that the area on the bottom of the coil where that spring contacts it looked to have some type of crud/coating on it, so I sanded it clean.

Called it a night after all of that. Went for a short-ish drive this morning before work and had no cutout/stumbling issues, but I'll have to drive it more to feel like it's really fixed.

I think the rod spring swap really helped, there's more power coming on faster when accelerating from part-throttle. I got to pass a Toyota Matrix who was doing 40 on a 50 MPH road, I won't say it was really "like she was standing still" but it sure as hell felt like it when driving a big honkin' Jeep from the 70's :D Highest I'd pushed the revs to date. I really need a tach ;)

I'll update this as I drive it more, more thoughts/suggestions are welcome though!
'77 Cherokee S - EFI 401
'84 Alaskan Postal Scrambler
'18 JKU Rubi Recon
'01 XJ - kid's DD
'01 XJ - winter beater
'18 Renegade
User avatar

Topic author
bigwalton
Posts: 161
Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2012 10:33 am
Location: MI

Re: Intermittent engine cutout issue, ideas?

Post by bigwalton »

Updating this after more driving. Some combination of what I did in that last post worked. Haven't had any cutting out since. I tend to think it was the ignition switch plug being loose.
'77 Cherokee S - EFI 401
'84 Alaskan Postal Scrambler
'18 JKU Rubi Recon
'01 XJ - kid's DD
'01 XJ - winter beater
'18 Renegade
Post Reply