Hey Wagontail,
I hear you on the carpet. I searched and stressed about the carpet for months- nothing seemed right.
I ended up calling and talking to Ryan (I think) at BJs off-road. There is really only one company that makes carpet kits for FSJs. Comes in 3 flavors; Essex (deep pile) Cute pile (short pile) and loop. The Essex is probably closer to the factory depth but does not come in the right color blue, loop is very difficult to keep clean and is not close to factory plus does not come in the correct color blue. Leaving the only option to go with cut pile. (Sometimes not having an option is best).
I can’t remember which color of blue Cut pile I ordered (I went with the color Ryan suggested). I ordered a sample first. The sample is actually a really good deal - I was expecting a little 4” square but I got 1-1/2 yards. I’m going to see if Tito can make me some floor mats from the extra material.
The color is actually very close to factory but it is not as deep or as dense. The kit comes with padding, which I was not expecting. Unfortunately, The padding is pretty lousy. I ended up using a combination of some padding I bought on amazon ( I think the brand was design engineering) plus the padding it came with for extra plush squishy-ness.
The fit is pretty good. The only complaint I have is that the factory carpet has a small cardboard backed piece (that was not salvageable in my case) that goes around the the little hump between the front and back seats. This carpet kit just wraps over the hump and the fits is a bit saggy.
I hope that helps. Let me know if you have any other questions.
Paul
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk