This was a real mind bender, I have worked on it since noon and my last effort was successful.
An hour ago I was ready to go to the pet store and buy an air valve for an aquarium pump and screw it to the dash
Pretty simple switch, one vacuum port and two to pulling the defrost and heater actuators. I had the switch apart at least a dozen times and could hear a slight vacuum leak but it was not pulling even 1Hg on the gauge. I could not see any way that the switch had a gasket because I could see wear marks between the two halves. I tried polishing with Mother's aluminum mag polish, adding a film of grease and nothing worked.
When I pulled the cluster out I used a spring punch to mark the hose ports. I began to think this might have cause a high spot to form so I took a fine flat file and rubbed the area near the pings and noticed a shiny spot.
So I took valve grinding compound and lapped the two halves, then I took 2000 grit wet/dry paper and polished each halve on the glass stove top. I put a fine film of grease on one side and reassembled it. I fired up the engine, connected the lines and it SNAPS those actuators faster than ever.
So, if you peen the valve with a spring punch to mark the hoses this is how you make the repair